2024 ASEC Best Article Prize
This year’s ASEC’s best article prize is being shared by two outstanding case studies that could not be more different from each other in subject matter, but which share impressive empirical research within effective analytical theoretical frameworks and present us with persuasive revisionist ideas about identities in the religious and secular realms. In methodological terms one piece — the first in alphabetical order by authors — is more anthropological and the other more sociological in nature. Please note that both articles are based on evidence gathered prior to the Russian unprovoked invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.
In alphabetical order by authors:
Irina Paert, Liina Eek, and Andrei Sõtšov’s “Beyond Ethnocentric Identity: Understanding Orthodox Communalities in Estonia,” Journal of Baltic Studies (2023).
Based on over 100 interviews conducted in Estonia between 2012 and 2021 (at the end of the COVID epidemic) with Estonian and Russian speakers who identify themselves as Orthodox, the article challenges scholars to abandon the dominant paradigm that equates religious identity with secular ethnic, national, and political differences. Estonia’s multi-ethnic minority Orthodox population is divided jurisdictionally, but not ethnically, into two different church structures that are at present in canonical tension with one another. This Orthodox population provides the perfect test case for uncovering believers’ religious identities by way of their rhetoric and quotidian practices. Within this dynamic period of religious revival, Paert, Eek, and Sõtšov found believers searching for a “post-secular response to the failure of modernity and postmodernity to provide” answers about the meaning of humanity. Those answers for both clerical and lay believers, the authors argue, come from their shared concept of sobornost as belonging to a timeless ecclesial community (if expressed in a variety of ways) and the importance that the Eucharist, the parish, and the church family play in their daily lives. Ultimately, the authors persuasively argue it is incumbent upon scholars to “listen to the stories that Orthodox believers tell” about their religious beliefs and “interactions with other believers, sacred spaces, and objects” by using notions of ecclesial and eucharistic communities as effective analytical categories so as to avoid the pitfalls of political and confessional reductionism.
Jeanne Kormina, “‘The church should know its place’: The passions and the interests of urban struggle in post-atheist Russia,” History and Anthropology (2020).
In her case study of the protests in St. Petersburg in the winter and spring of 2017 evoked by the authorities’ diktat to transfer St. Isaac’s Cathedral from state ownership to church ownership, Kormina, an expert on post-Soviet Russian Orthodoxy, brings into focus the tensions over the control of cultural property that can arise in the post-Soviet era within a less than “true secular state” with a decidedly “distinctive church-state nexus.” In interviews with secularists and believers and the use of letters to the editor of the internet newspaper Fontanka, the author deftly shows the ways in which professional and white-collar guardians of the Soviet “sacralization of ‘culture'” and redefinition of religion as “heritage” expressed a “passionate secularism,” a concept borrowed from the political theorist Albert Hirschman. These guardians did so by championing the maintenance of cultural monuments in the name of the common good as opposed to what they perceived as the particularist and “superstitious” religious claims of some Orthodox believers. Conflicted highly educated Orthodox believers could be found among the secularists. Kormina shows how the Russian Orthodox Church (MP) had become the real enemy in the secularists’ eyes in its role as a representative of the post-Soviet authoritarian state that wished to deprive its populace of a revered public space. They viewed the church as illegitimately claiming the right to control what had been state property and therefore public space not only in the Soviet period, but also from its inception as a consecrated church in the Imperial period. In Kormina’s superb analysis this emotional fight against the Church represented a victory for a fledgling modern public sphere in an urban setting or what some of us might term a civil society.
Respectfully submitted by Nina Shultz and Christine Worobec

Comments
2024 ASEC Best Article Prize — No Comments
HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>